Justia Alaska Supreme Court Opinion Summaries
Kelly R. v. State
This case involves the placement of a child, Sunny, who was taken into custody by the Alaska Office of Children’s Services (OCS) after being found in her mother’s care with signs of drug exposure. Sunny was initially placed with unrelated foster parents. Her biological sister, Brianna, had previously been placed with and adopted by Kelly and Brian Randall, who reside in Tennessee. OCS considered placing Sunny with the Randalls, facilitating visits to prepare for a possible transfer, but Sunny’s mother and current foster parents opposed this move.The Superior Court for the Third Judicial District, Palmer, held a placement review hearing after Sunny’s mother requested one, and Kelly Randall filed a proxy petition for Sunny’s adoption. The court denied both the proposed transfer to the Randalls and Kelly’s adoption petition, finding by clear and convincing evidence that relocating Sunny to Tennessee would be contrary to her best interests. Importantly, the court declined to apply the statutory presumption under AS 47.10.080(w) that maintaining a sibling relationship is in the child’s best interest, reasoning that no such relationship existed between Sunny and Brianna due to their separate upbringing. When Kelly requested another placement review hearing, OCS and the court relied on the prior findings and again denied the request.On appeal, the Supreme Court of Alaska reviewed the denial of Kelly’s placement request and consolidated appeals. The court held that the statutory presumption favoring maintenance of sibling relationships applies to siblings related by blood, regardless of whether legal ties have been severed by adoption or whether an emotional or social relationship exists. The Supreme Court found that the superior court erred by not applying this presumption in its assessment of good cause to deviate from statutory placement preferences. The order denying Kelly’s request was vacated and the matter remanded for further proceedings. View "Kelly R. v. State" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law
Bowen v. Ray
A married couple with four children separated in March 2022, and the wife filed for divorce in May 2022. During the proceedings, the husband, a pediatric dentist and National Guard member, submitted financial documents significantly understating his income. Based on his reported income, the Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Palmer, issued an interim child support order requiring him to pay $697.94 per month. The wife later presented evidence showing the husband earned substantially more than reported, including a new position with a $176,000 salary and additional income streams.After a motion to vacate the original child support order, supported by documentary evidence of the husband’s true income, the superior court issued a new order increasing the monthly obligation to $3,780, retroactive to the month the husband began his higher-paying job. The husband challenged this as an impermissible retroactive modification under Alaska Civil Rule 90.3(h) and argued that the evidence regarding his income and the division of equity in a property titled to his parents was insufficient. The superior court found the husband’s testimony and supporting documents established that his income exceeded the cap for child support calculations. Furthermore, the court found that the couple had acquired an equity interest in the property known as Silver Springs, based on evidence that the husband made monthly payments to his parents with the intention of eventual ownership, making the equity marital property subject to division.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska held that Civil Rule 90.3 does not shield a parent who knowingly underreports income from a retroactive increase in support obligations. The court affirmed the superior court’s findings regarding both the child support calculation and the marital estate’s equity interest in the Silver Springs property, upholding the rulings in all respects. View "Bowen v. Ray" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law
Jonah O. v. State
An infant, identified as an Indian child due to his mother’s tribal affiliation, was placed by his mother with a relative, also an Indian person, who acted as the child’s primary caregiver for several years. The child’s father was uninvolved, incarcerated, and lacked a relationship with the child. After reports of neglect and abuse by the relative surfaced, the Office of Children’s Services (OCS) and the Village tribal authority removed the child from the relative’s care. OCS initially considered returning the child to the mother but found her circumstances unsuitable and subsequently assumed emergency custody. The Tribe intervened in the child in need of aid proceedings. The superior court eventually placed the child in the mother’s care under OCS supervision, later returned him to foster care, and OCS petitioned to terminate parental rights.The Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Anchorage, handled the child in need of aid proceedings. The relative, claiming status as an Indian custodian under the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), requested party status and court-appointed counsel. The superior court initially found that any Indian custodianship had dissolved once the child was returned to the mother. The relative appealed, and the Alaska Supreme Court remanded the case for the purpose of allowing the relative to intervene. On remand, the superior court allowed intervention, but the father, who retained residual parental rights, moved to revoke the Indian custodianship.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska reviewed the appeal. It held that a parent with residual rights may revoke an Indian custodianship established by temporary transfer, even over the objection of the parent who created the custodianship. The court affirmed the superior court’s order, finding no error in recognizing the father’s revocation of the Indian custodianship and denying the relative ongoing party status as Indian custodian. View "Jonah O. v. State" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, Native American Law
State v. Albertsons Companies, Inc.
The State of Alaska sued several major retail pharmacies, alleging their practices contributed significantly to the opioid epidemic in Alaska. The State claimed these pharmacies failed to monitor, investigate, and report illegitimate opioid prescriptions, as required by federal and state controlled substances laws. The complaint alleged that such failures led to widespread opioid diversion, increased availability of prescription opioids, and a marked rise in addiction, overdose deaths, strain on healthcare and law enforcement systems, and harm to families and children. The State further asserted these actions constituted a public nuisance and violated the Alaska Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Act (UTPA).The State brought suit in the Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Anchorage, seeking injunctive relief and penalties under the UTPA, as well as abatement of the public nuisance. The pharmacies jointly moved to dismiss, arguing their conduct was exempt from the UTPA due to ongoing regulation and did not amount to public nuisance because the sale of lawful products cannot constitute such a claim and their actions were not the proximate cause of harm. The superior court granted the motion, holding that the alleged conduct was exempt from the UTPA and that the State failed to allege unreasonable interference with a public right, referencing City of Chicago v. Beretta U.S.A. Corp.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of Alaska reviewed the superior court’s dismissal de novo. The court affirmed the dismissal of most UTPA claims, holding the pharmacies’ conduct was regulated and thus exempt, except for one claim regarding deceptive promotion of compliance efforts, which was not specifically prohibited and thus survived. The court reversed the dismissal of the public nuisance claim, holding the State sufficiently alleged the pharmacies’ failures unreasonably interfered with public health and safety and declined to categorically bar public nuisance claims involving product sales. The case was remanded for further proceedings. View "State v. Albertsons Companies, Inc." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Consumer Law
Beachcomber, LLC v. Kenai Peninsula Borough Planning Commission
A limited liability company owned rural property and applied for a conditional land use permit to operate a gravel pit mine on part of its land. The local borough code required applicants in the rural district to obtain such permits for material excavation, with standards aimed at minimizing noise and visual impacts. The borough’s planning commission held multiple public hearings, received substantial community opposition, and ultimately denied the application. The commission found that due to the property’s unique topography, no combination of permitted buffer zones or berms could sufficiently mitigate noise and visual disturbances to neighboring properties.The company appealed the denial to a borough hearing officer, who interpreted the code as limiting the commission’s discretion and remanded the case. The commission then approved the application. Neighboring residents appealed to another hearing officer, who affirmed the approval, but the matter was further appealed to the Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District. The superior court reversed the approval, holding that the borough code granted the commission discretion to deny permits if it determined the conditions would not adequately minimize impacts. On remand, the commission again denied the application, finding substantial evidence that the standards could not be met due to the site’s amphitheater-like topography. This denial was affirmed by a hearing officer and the superior court, which found substantial evidence supported the commission’s findings and rejected procedural and due process challenges.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska reviewed the case. It held that the borough code provided the planning commission discretion to deny conditional land use permits if, based on substantial evidence, it determined that no combination of permitted conditions could adequately minimize noise disturbance and visual impacts. The court also found no merit in procedural or due process arguments and affirmed the commission’s permit denial and the superior court decisions. View "Beachcomber, LLC v. Kenai Peninsula Borough Planning Commission" on Justia Law
King v. Carty
A man and a woman were in a committed romantic relationship for nearly eight years, during which they had a child and operated joint businesses. After they separated, the man initiated a lawsuit seeking division of assets he claimed were acquired during their domestic partnership. The parties agreed that they had a domestic partnership, which under Alaska law means a relationship in which they intended to share assets as though married. However, they disagreed on whether certain assets—a building the man owned before the relationship and a boat acquired during the partnership but titled and paid for solely by the man—were partnership property subject to division.The Superior Court for the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Dillingham found that all disputed assets, including the building and the boat, were partnership property. The court reasoned that the building, though purchased and built by the man before the relationship, was essential to the operation of one of their joint businesses, and that the boat, although acquired with the man’s separate funds and titled solely in his name, was intended for partnership use. The court ordered a 50/50 division of these assets and required the man to pay an equalization amount to the woman. The man moved for reconsideration, challenging the classification and valuation of the building and the boat, but the Superior Court denied reconsideration.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of Alaska held that property acquired before a domestic partnership begins is not subject to the special rules for partnership property and remains the owner’s separate property. It further held that, for property acquired during a domestic partnership, the tracing doctrine applies: if an item is acquired solely with one party’s separate funds and titled in that person’s name, it remains separate property. The court reversed the Superior Court’s rulings on both the building and the boat and remanded for further proceedings. View "King v. Carty" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, Real Estate & Property Law
Dash D. v. State
The appellant, a father of six Indian children, challenged the termination of his parental rights under the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). The Office of Children’s Services (OCS) took emergency custody of the children after receiving reports of neglect, including unsanitary living conditions and food insecurity. The father tested positive for multiple substances, and an initial out-of-home safety plan with a relative failed. OCS placed the children with their aunt, a preferred ICWA placement, and initiated proceedings for temporary custody, adjudication, disposition, and ultimately, termination of parental rights. Throughout the case, the father was represented by counsel at various stages, sometimes proceeding pro se, and repeatedly claimed he did not receive discovery materials.The Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Palmer, held hearings at each stage. Temporary custody was granted after expedited hearings, with findings that removal was necessary to prevent imminent harm. The father stipulated to probable cause for the children being in need of aid, reserving the right to contest at adjudication. Subsequent hearings resulted in approval of OCS’s permanency plan. The father failed to comply with his case plan, and OCS filed for termination. Multiple motions by the father, alleging ICWA and constitutional violations, were rejected by the superior court, which found OCS had complied with ICWA at all stages.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of Alaska reviewed three procedural arguments: denial of discovery, improper emergency removal, and alleged ICWA violations in earlier foster care proceedings. The court held that the superior court did not abuse its discretion regarding discovery, that OCS’s emergency removal complied with ICWA and Alaska law, and that alleged errors in earlier foster care actions did not invalidate the later, separate termination action. The court affirmed the termination order, finding no reversible error. View "Dash D. v. State" on Justia Law
Dickerson v. Dickerson
A married couple with three minor children separated after more than a decade together, leading to divorce proceedings focused on property and custody issues. The central dispute concerned the proceeds from the sale of the marital home, which had been purchased in part with funds that one spouse received as an inheritance. During the marriage, the home increased in value, and the parties disagreed about whether the inheritance funds and their appreciated value should be considered separate or marital property. Additional disputes included whether proceeds from the sale of a neighboring property to a family member should be part of the marital estate and whether credits or adjustments were owed for post-separation expenses and exclusive use of the marital home.The Superior Court for the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Homer, conducted a property division trial. The court credited the wife’s testimony that her inheritance funds used for the down payment remained her separate property, but classified the increase in the home’s value as marital. It ordered an equal division of marital property, enforced a payment promised by the wife to the husband to facilitate the home sale, denied claims for credits and imputed rental value, and required each party to pay their own attorney’s fees. The court issued a child support order based on information provided by the wife after the husband failed to submit requested documentation.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska reversed the Superior Court’s ruling that the inheritance funds remained separate property, holding that when separate property is commingled with marital property, a presumption arises that it becomes marital unless rebutted by sufficient evidence. Uncorroborated testimony about intent is insufficient to overcome this presumption. The court affirmed the remainder of the Superior Court’s rulings, including the equal division of marital property, denial of credits and imputed rental value, enforcement of the agreed payment, child support award, and attorney’s fees. The matter was remanded for further proceedings consistent with the opinion. View "Dickerson v. Dickerson" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Family Law, Real Estate & Property Law
In re Necessity for the Hospitalization of Derius L.
A man with a lengthy history of severe mental illness, homelessness, and repeated hospitalizations was admitted multiple times to the Alaska Psychiatric Institute (API), most recently seeking shelter during winter. He has diagnoses including schizoaffective disorder, traumatic brain injury, and polysubstance dependence, and has frequently been barred from local shelters and facilities due to his behavior. After his admission in early 2024, API staff observed his acute psychosis, noncompliance with outpatient treatment, and declining condition. There was discussion of a possible discharge plan involving relocation to live with family in Arizona, but concerns were raised about his ability to safely travel, the sufficiency of supports available there, and his own reluctance to leave Alaska.The Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Anchorage, first granted a 30-day involuntary commitment and authorization for administration of psychotropic medication, then later extended the commitment for 90 days. At the 90-day hearing, testimony indicated that less restrictive alternatives, including discharge to family, were considered but not feasible at that time. The court also approved a renewed petition for involuntary medication after finding that the man lacked the capacity to make informed medical decisions and had not previously, while competent, expressed a clear wish to refuse such medication. The man did not file timely objections to the master’s findings.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska reviewed the case under the plain error standard, given the absence of objections below. The court held that while it was a clear error for the superior court to proceed without confirming whether the man was advised of the option for voluntary treatment, this mistake was not obviously prejudicial because the record indicated he would not have accepted voluntary admission. The Supreme Court also found no plain error in the lower court’s conclusions that no less restrictive alternative was available and that the requirements for involuntary medication were satisfied. The superior court’s orders were affirmed. View "In re Necessity for the Hospitalization of Derius L." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Health Law
Donkel v. State of Alaska
An individual asserted interests in six oil leases that were proposed for inclusion in an oil exploration and development unit on Alaska’s North Slope. The Alaska Division of Oil and Gas initially approved two of these leases for unit inclusion but later reversed its position and denied inclusion for all six. During the administrative appeal process, the leases expired because the lessees failed to pay the required rental payments, as mandated by a Department of Natural Resources (DNR) regulation. The individual did not pay the rent necessary to reinstate the leases, and the Division confirmed their termination.The individual appealed both the termination of the leases and the denial of their inclusion in the unit to the Commissioner of Natural Resources. The Commissioner affirmed the terminations and denied the inclusion request. Separate appeals were filed in the Alaska Superior Court: one challenging the lease terminations (raising the validity of the rent-during-appeal regulation) and one challenging the denial of unit inclusion (alleging agency overreach, unreasonableness, and due process violations). The Superior Court affirmed the termination of five leases and remanded the sixth for further proceedings regarding its production capabilities. It also affirmed the denial of unit inclusion, finding no violation of due process or agency overreach.The Supreme Court of the State of Alaska held that the DNR regulation requiring rental payments during the pendency of an appeal is constitutional and a reasonable exercise of DNR’s authority. Because the lessees failed to pay rent, the terminations of five leases were affirmed, rendering the unitization appeal for those leases moot. The dispute over the sixth lease was found to remain live, but the Commissioner’s denial of its inclusion in the unit was affirmed as neither arbitrary, unreasonable, nor a violation of due process. The award of attorney’s fees against the appellant was also affirmed. View "Donkel v. State of Alaska" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Energy, Oil & Gas Law, Government & Administrative Law